Everything is negotiable, Already sold, Keep the hard bargaining for the car lot.
9/20/2026 9:15:00 AM | By JWS | Comment on this

Full Moon Rising on the Madison
No one should drive a hard bargain with an artist.
Ludwig van Beethoven
I was talking to my neighbor at the fence a few weeks ago. She is an accomplished artist and mentioned she is no longer accepting commissions. It seems buyers want too much input, forgetting it was the artist's techniques and artistic viewpoint that drew them to the artist in the first place.
I have also stopped accepting commissions for different reasons. My painting process is slow. The time involved, even for a small painting, can be too much for many buyers, even though I explain this upfront. After too many check-ins from buyers about progress, I decided to focus my output on online sales. After my last gallery experience, I don't think I will be doing that going forward. Not using a gallery, however, puts you in the middle of transactions.
Most interactions with buyers and art patrons are enjoyable, but it is hard to please everyone. A buyer who came to the studio spent a long time studying one of my paintings and asked several questions. Finally, she said, " I want to buy the painting, but I need the frame changed. I told her that after she bought the painting, she could change the frame to anything she wanted. She then asked how much it would cost without the frame. "The same," was my reply. "That makes no sense," was her comeback. I explained that all my frames are free. I have no interest in changing them out, but I would be happy to remove the painting from the frame so she could take it to a frame shop and have it framed however she liked. She mentioned that her father had told her everything is negotiable, and she expected a discount if the painting was unframed. I politely told her that a meeting of the minds was not going to happen that day, and it was time for her to leave, as I had another appointment. I also mentioned a gallery in town she might want to visit. They represent several landscape artists and have their own framing service, and could help with the framing.
A week later, she showed up at my studio unannounced and said she would take the painting as framed. I told her the painting had been sold. She seemed mad at me or perhaps just mad in general as she left.
I try to be upfront with patrons and enjoy pleasant transactions. Buying a painting should be a good experience for both the artist and the buyer, but artists generally don't appreciate a hard-bargaining approach. A painting in not a used car. There's no dealer's margin built into the price, so we can't haggle our way toward a number that makes everyone happy. If you are a one-off buyer, don't ask for a discount. If you have purchased multiple paintings from the same artist, then by all means, feel free to ask. Most artists will appreciate your loyalty and may want to reward it. But for the one-off purchases? Keep the hard bargaining for the car lot.